Citronella collar reviews


We analyzed reviews for the most popular Citronella anti bark collars available on the market(read about our accurate unbiased method).

We compared them side-by-side, and scored them according to a range of factors including ease of use, functionality, safety and durability.

Below you will find top ranked collars (click on the product name to read the full review).

Top ranked Citronella bark collars How We Test
Our Ranking #1 #2 #3
Product Name
petsafe gentle spray
PetSafe Gentle Spray
Read the review

 

Intellipet Citronella Anti-Bark Dog Collar
Intellipet citronella collar
Read the review

 

NO BARK Citronella Spray Anti-Bark Collar
NO BARK Collar
Read the review

 

Editors’ Awards editors choice best buy
Price $39
Buy at Amazon
$77
Buy at Amazon
$29
Buy at Amazon
Overall Score
100
0
95
100
0
82
100
0
75
Editors’ Rating 5 Stars (5 / 5) 4.5 Stars (4.5 / 5) 4.5 Stars (4.5 / 5)
User Rating 4.7 Stars (4.7 / 5) 4.7 Stars (4.7 / 5) 4 Stars (4 / 5)
Date Reviewed Feb 15, 2015 Feb 15, 2015 Feb 15, 2015
Scores PetSafe Gentle Spray Intellipet citronella collar NO BARK Collar
Performance
10
0
9
10
0
8.9
10
0
8.4
Ease of use
10
0
9.5
10
0
8.8
10
0
7.9
Safety
10
0
9.5
10
0
7.7
10
0
7.8
Durability
10
0
9.8
10
0
8.9
10
0
6

We will outline the basics of manufacturers, distinguishing between existing types of citronella collars and what collar will suit your pet best.

How do these collars work?

A citronella collar might sound like a weird thing, if you’ve never heard of it, but it is an anti-bark device; essentially, a collar that releases a citronella fragrance when its attached microphone or vibration sensor detects that your dog is barking. It’s important to note that the spray used is plant-based and therefore, entirely safe for the animal. A citronella collar definitely makes a better alternative to using shock collars for dogs, which are largely regarded as inhumane and are even illegal, in some places.

You might be wondering how it is supposed to work, exactly. A citronella collar is effective in curbing your pet’s barking, because dogs don’t like the smell of citronella and once they learn that barking results in being sprayed, they stop. It is not painful or harmful, but merely unpleasant, which is a gentle negative reinforcement, but strong enough for your dog to not want to trigger the fragrance by barking.

Usage

Anti-bark collars are devices that are used when your pet barks constantly, for no apparent reason and in absence of distress. They are often used for dogs who bark for prolonged periods of time when the owner is not present, which disturbs the neighbors. It is an effective tool in discouraging and controlling a behavioral problem that has not been otherwise successfully resolved in training sessions and with professional help. One of the major advantages is that the device is customizable and can be set to only go off after a certain number of barks, thus ensuring its most effective use.

The Pros and Cons of Using Citronella Collars

Not every pet device is suitable for every pet or every owner, which is why it is important to research before you buy and decide whether or not a citronella collar is what you need, once you have all the appropriate information and the pros and cons of citronella collars.

As far as anti-bark solutions go, a citronella collar is the most humane, because it does not harm your pet in any way. It releases a citronella smell that is unpleasant for dogs and which will discourage them from barking, in order to avoid it. It usually takes a few sprays before they figure it out, but once they learn, the anti-bark collar can even be replaced by a normal one, but the placebo effect will continue to work and they will not start barking again.

On the other hand, not only the dog will smell the citronella – you will, too. After a few sprays, your dog will smell like it, so if you are not too keen on the scent, maybe the device is not for you. In addition, citronella collars from most manufacturers (PetSafe, GentleSpray, Innotek) must be recharged after 20-30 sprays, which is an added cost you should be aware of, before purchasing.

Choosing a Citronella Collar Suitable for Your Dog

Collars are not one-size-fits-all, which is good, because when you are choosing a collar, you have to take your pet into consideration. Keep in mind things like age, size, breed and temperament, as well as the frequency with which he barks. The best course of action is to take your pet with you when you shop, as most places will allow you to try the collar on before you buy it. Always make sure that it fits properly and is comfortable; this cannot be stressed enough.

Because every dog is unique, every collar will have to be personalized, to some extent. For example, a puppy or a smaller-breed dog will need a smaller, thinner collar, while a big dog will benefit from a sturdier one. Owners of long-haired dogs should ensure that the pet’s fur is not obstructing the spray nozzle. The collar should be comfortable at all times and never be too tight, because your pet might risk chocking because of air passage restriction.

The collars can be made from plastic, fabric or leather and it is up to you to decide what your pet prefers. The fabric ones are lighter, but they get dirty and damaged quicker, while the leather ones are more comfortable for your dog, but they are also heavier and more expensive.

Safety and Side Effects

Another important aspect to consider is whether or not the presence of a citronella collar will inhibit or restrict your dog’s movement, energy and activities and if there are other effects you should be aware of. The answer is no, a citronella collar does not have unpleasant side effects on your dog (apart from smelling like citronella, which we discussed earlier) and it will allow them to continue their normal activity. They can run around, jump, play and even get wet with no issue whatsoever, as the collar is waterproof and will not get damaged. In addition, it will create no problems for users of invisible fences and it will not interfere with their effectiveness.

Keep these things in mind when you are shopping for an anti-bark collar for your pet and you will be guaranteed to have a positive experience. The most important thing to remember is to choose something that is suitable for your pet’s needs, as well as your own and always consider your dog’s comfort a priority. When chosen correctly, a citronella collar should not inconvenience your pet and have only positive effects in discouraging their irritating barking habit.

Detailed reviews

Petsafe Premier GentleSpray

GentleSpray Citronella Anti-Bark DogThe GentleSpray Citronella Anti-Bark Collar is a pet-safe and premier anti-bark collar available today that will provide the solution to stop the bad behavior of your nuisance-barking dog.

Through the GentleSpray Citronella Anti-Bark Collar, the dog is conditioned to stop its excessant barking through a spray of Citronella at the front of the dog’s snout whenever it barks. The Gentle Spray Citronella Anti-Bark Spray collar is a combination of advanced spray technology and modern electronics.

NO BARK Collar Citronella Spray Anti-Bark Collar

NO BARK Collar Citronella Spray Anti-Bark CollarThe Citronella Spray No Bark Dog Collar works a lot like other no bark collars, but has an extra advantage. Just like in the case of the other collars, it has a sensor that only activates when the dog barks. However, instead of releasing an electric shock, it gives a burst of citronella spray. This is enough to convince your dog that barking is not allowed. The collar does a good job in identifying barking and it does not release the spray in case of external noise.

Innotek Anti-Bark Spray Collar, Citronella

Innotek Anti-Bark Spray CollarThe Innotek Anti-Bark Citronella Collar is one of the most effective anti-bark collars available in the market today. Here is basically how Innotek Anti-Bark Spray Collar works. When the dog barks, the collar emits harmless sprays to tell the dog to stop barking. The spray is safe and does not have any side effect.

Based on research, the Innotek Anti-Bark Spray Collar is highly effective in reducing the incessant barking of dogs. This includes Citronella refills. Unscented refills can also be purchased if you want no-scent sprays. For the first-time users, here is how the Innotek Anti-Bark Spray collar is used. First, you have to make sure that the adjustable strap fits your dog, and then, you would have to wait nearby until your dog barks. In most cases, the dog quickly recognizes that the sprays tell the dog to stop barking.

More reviews